If you were eating it entirely on its own roast turkey would be one of the easiest ingredients in the world to match. You could drink your favourite white, red, ros or even sparkling wine with it and it would work fine.
The problem comes with what you put with it - a full-flavoured, fruity, sometimes spicy stuffing, tart cranberry sauce and an array of vegetables (sprouts and carrots at a minimum) that means you probably have about a dozen different flavours on your plate. That doesn’t mean you can’t still pick a white or rosé but it does suggest something full and fruity that can cope with the onslaught.
The other consideration should be who you have round the table as both Thanksgiving and Christmas tend to be multi-generational gatherings involving older members of the family who may well be set in their ways. So it’s worth sticking to tried and tested crowd pleasers:
My top picks would be:
What I wouldn’t do is pull out some aged and venerable bottle that you’ve been keeping for a special occasion. There’s always a danger that it will disappoint and that the cranberry sauce will just slaughter it.
When it comes to cold turkey think in terms of a slightly lighter red like a Pinot Noir or (my own favourite) a chilled cru Beaujolais or good Beaujolais Villages.
Image © msheldrake - Fotolia.com